Etsy Design Awards

Finalists Judging Instructions

Please review each Etsy Design Award finalist on the six criteria below, ranking each on a scale of 1-10 stars. You also have the option to leave a comment to accompany your review (which we would recommend for your top picks!). When you’re done with each review, hit the ‘submit’ button to finalize your grading.

• Quality

  Overall level of craftsmanship and skill.

• Creativity & innovation

  Is the item unique or imaginative?

• Utility & functionality

  Is the item functional? Does it serve its purpose?

• ‘Wow’ factor

  Is the item stunning?

• Personal story

  The maker or curator story.

• Top-notch branding

  Does the shop feature clear, compelling descriptions, excellent customer service, and high-quality photography?